MULCH so Many Benefits and so Many Choices

Why Mulch?   

  • Mulch adds nutrients to the soil and increases soil microbes. Soil microbes are responsible for breaking down organic matter and organic fertilizers and converting them into nutrients that the plants can easily absorb.
  • Mulch holds in moisture, reducing watering requirements and keeps the soil at a more consistent moisture level.
  • Mulch suppresses weeds by shutting out light and any weed seeds that do germinate are usually very easy to pull up.
  • Mulch reduces soil compaction.
  • Mulch improves a soils structure.
  • Mulch reduces splash up from rain and overhead watering. This helps to prevent fungal diseases in the garden.
  • Mulch keeps soil cooler in summer and shades roots.
  • Mulch insulates the soil in the winter and helps to reduce soil temperature fluctuations that can create winter kill.
  • Mulch can greatly enhance the appearance of your beds and borders.

When to Mulch?  

The best time to mulch is after you have finished planting in May. By this time your soil should be sufficiently warmed. By this time you should also be pretty much finished disturbing the soil surface. Mulching to early, before your soil temperature has a chance to warm, will slow down root and plant growth . Major soil disturbances after mulching may require additional mulch.

  • Cocoa Bean Hulls (Are known for their chocolaty aroma which can last for approximately two weeks. They are best used in a sunny location as they tend to mold in shadier, moister locations. This mold is not harmful to the soil or the plant but it is not the most visually appealing. Cocoa Bean Hulls tend to break down very quickly and need to be replaced yearly. They also add potassium to the soil . Potassium is a necessary mineral; it helps to regulate a plants metabolism and contributes to early growth, stem strength, hardiness, vigor, good flower colour and disease resistance. It is also essential for the proper development of root crops. However care must be taken as to much potassium will tie up magnesium (making it unavailable to the plants) another necessary mineral. Apply only a thin layer of this mulch approximately 1” thick. I personally like Marjorie Harris, like to mix my cocoa bean hulls ½ and ½ with sheep manure.
  • Compost provides nutrients to the soil and increases microbial activity. Compost helps to prevent weed seeds from germinating. It is one of the most natural looking mulches.
  • Decorative Shredded wood mulches: costs a fortune per square foot of coverage, but nothing looks finer, available in an amazing array of designer textures and colors, does need replenishing though
  • Pine Bark Nuggets (although attractive they are not your best choice as they tend to draw moisture out of the soil rather than hold it in.)
  • Ground covers (living mulch) periwinkle, lamuim, thyme, pachysandra, viola, etc. While they do help to reduce both weeds by choking them out they can be hard to weed out.
  • Decorative stone: quite expensive though. If you change your mind, it takes a lot of work to remove the product. Also, since it does not break down there is no nutritional benefit for the soil. It is also very difficult to divide your perennials with a rock mulch type. A heavy duty landscape cloth is usually used under the stone to more fully prevent weeds. On the down side because it does not break down it does not nourish your soil thus fertilizing will be all the more important and expensive. Also weed seed especially grass seeds can take root in amongst the stone and they are very difficult to weed out).
  • Grass clippings are free and readily available to most home owners. They are high in nitrogen.
  • Straw – the ultimate temporary winter mulch for tender perennials and lower shrubs
  • Shredded tree and shrub materials extremely cheap (sometimes free!), highly effective as organic material but needs frequent replenishing, can be overly dirty (e.g. weed seeds, insects, disease)
  • Pine Needles (can help acidify alkaline soils, they are readily available, usually free, best for woodland gardens)
  • Leaves are plentiful and free. If your trees do not provide enough leaves for your needs neighbours will usually be more than willing to let you have some of theirs. Allow the leaves to dry then chop them up by running over them with a lawnmower, weed whackers work well as do shredders. Once shredded apply a layer to your beds and borders in late fall)… not apply to early as it is advantageous to expose over wintering insects to the cold to kill as many of them off as you can before you mulch. Mulching to early provides a safe nesting place for undesirable insects to overwinter.
  • News paper is a great organic means of suppressing weeds. Simply lay down a layer of wetted down news papers (that are several sheets thick) and cover them with another mulch material to weight them down. The news papers completely block out light to soil thus preventing weeds. This technique works well in areas where you do not wish to plant or are unable to grow anything, except perhaps a few weeds (like along the shady narrow side of a house).   
  • Landscape Cloth Landscape fabric is a specially designed, permeable fabric, most often made of woven polypropylene. It may be laid underneath your mulch to further block sunlight from reaching weed seeds and to keep air borne seeds from making contact with the soil.  There are both benefits and draw backs to using landscape cloth so consider its use carefully.
    • Pros to using Landscape Cloth:
      • Are excellent for under decks, gravel paths, stone mulches and  paving stones
      • They are suitable for short term weed suppression in vegetable beds.
      • Good barrier against invasive roots and digging/ tunneling pests
      • Makes a good pot liner.
      • Good for erosion control.
    • Cons to using Landscape Cloth
      • Weeds that sprout in the mulch and penetrate the cloth are difficult to weed out and may tear the cloth when they are pulled.  
      • The mulch will be prevented from enriching the soil and building up the soil microbial population. (Mulch must have contact with the soil to perform this function.)
      • The cloth prevents the incorporation of fertilizer and soil amendments. These also need to be in contact with the soil in order to perform their functions. 
      • Interferes with planting and trans-planting (the cloth needs to be cut).
      • Prevents natural plant growth. The cloth must be continuously cut wider to accommodate new growth. Failure to do so may create girdling and even eventual death of the plant.
      • Installation and maintenance time. Once the cloth has been laid down and mulch placed on top you will find you are continuously have to redistribute the mulch to cover the cloth and keep it looking nice.
      • Contrary to what some manufactures claim they tend not to be a not long term solution.  Between tears, cuts and natural degrading the fabric life can be relatively short.

There are so many benefits to mulching including improving curb appeal and saving you hours of work in the garden. With so many types of mulch to choice from there is one to suit almost any need in the landscape.

Photo credits: all photos have been taken by the author.

All rights reserved

Terms of use: photos and content may be used for non-profit use and education with proper attribution and link back to page found.

For photos: Kimberley Pacholko MULCH so Many Benefits and so Many Choices – Horticulture For Home Gardeners

For content: Kimberley Pacholko 2021, Ornamental Garden Specialist, MULCH so Many Benefits and so Many Choices – Horticulture For Home Gardeners

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s